FailingCompany - Back to the Basics

We slightly took our focus off of AI last week. Instead, we examined how you can help address fear that your employees might have about AI. It's definitely a real thing and we learned that good old fashioned change management techniques can do a lot to help. No fancy AI solution needed to help the employees get comfortable.

That post got me thinking. Is there anywhere else where AI may not be the best bet? Can we get a little too excited and over-engineer a solution? You know what I had to do. It was time to ask ChatGPT what it thought.

Like last week, I'll share the prompt that I used for context. I asked ChatGPT, "Act as an expert AI consultant. Write a 1,500-word blog post on the top 5 times when a small business owner should NOT choose to implement AI. Provide specific examples for each of the top 5 things and describe why traditional methods are preferred." Will it have any suggestions at all?

"When to Hold Off on AI: Top 5 Scenarios for Small Business Owners
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing industries by automating tasks, enhancing decision-making, and improving customer experiences. However, AI is not a one-size-fits-all solution, and there are times when implementing it might not be the best choice, especially for small business owners. This blog post will explore the top five scenarios where traditional methods are preferred over AI, supported by specific examples.

1. When the Problem is Simple and Well-Defined
Example: A local bakery needs to manage customer orders and inventory.

In small businesses, many tasks are straightforward and require no complex decision-making or data analysis. For instance, a local bakery might need a system to manage customer orders, track inventory, and generate sales reports. While AI-driven inventory management systems exist, a simple point-of-sale (POS) system with built-in inventory tracking might be sufficient.

Why Traditional Methods are Preferred:

• Cost: Implementing AI can be expensive, with costs related to software, hardware, and training. For a small bakery, the return on investment might not justify the expense.


• Simplicity: Traditional POS systems are easier to set up and use, requiring little to no technical knowledge.


• Reliability: Established systems have been tried and tested for years, providing reliable performance without the complexities associated with AI.

In this scenario, the simplicity and cost-effectiveness of traditional methods outweigh the potential benefits of AI. A POS system can handle the bakery’s needs efficiently without the added complexity and expense of AI.

2. When the Business Lacks Sufficient Data
Example: A new boutique clothing store with minimal sales history.

AI thrives on data. It requires vast amounts of information to learn, make predictions, and provide valuable insights. A new boutique clothing store with limited sales history or customer data might not have enough data to feed an AI system. Without sufficient data, AI models can produce inaccurate or unreliable results.

Why Traditional Methods are Preferred:

• Data Scarcity: AI systems need data to learn and improve. A lack of data can lead to poor decision-making and a waste of resources.


• Human Insight: In the early stages of a business, human intuition and experience often guide decisions better than AI.


• Focus on Growth: Small businesses should focus on growth and gathering data rather than investing in AI solutions that may not yet be applicable.

In this case, traditional methods, such as relying on human judgment and basic analytics tools, are more appropriate until the business has accumulated enough data to benefit from AI.

3. When Personal Touch is Crucial
Example: A luxury wedding planning service that emphasizes personalized customer experiences.

In industries where customer relationships and personalized service are paramount, AI might not be the best fit. A luxury wedding planning service, for example, thrives on personal connections, understanding individual client needs, and providing bespoke solutions. While AI can help automate some tasks, like scheduling or managing contracts, it cannot replicate the human touch that is vital in such a business.

Why Traditional Methods are Preferred:

• Human Connection: In businesses where the personal touch is key, human interaction is irreplaceable. AI may automate processes, but it cannot replicate empathy, understanding, and the nuances of human relationships.


• Client Expectations: Clients paying for a premium service often expect direct interaction with humans, not automated systems.


• Customization: Personalized services require flexibility and creativity, areas where humans excel compared to AI.

For a luxury wedding planning service, maintaining a strong personal connection with clients is more important than automating processes with AI. Traditional methods allow for the level of customization and personal attention that clients expect.

4. When the Cost Outweighs the Benefits
Example: A small accounting firm considering AI-driven financial analysis tools.

AI can bring significant benefits, but it also comes with costs, including initial setup, ongoing maintenance, and the need for specialized staff or training. A small accounting firm might consider AI-driven financial analysis tools to enhance service offerings. However, the high cost of AI implementation might outweigh the benefits, particularly if the firm’s existing tools and methods are already meeting client needs.

Why Traditional Methods are Preferred:

• Budget Constraints: Small businesses often operate on tight budgets, making the cost of AI prohibitive.


• ROI Considerations: If the expected return on investment is low or uncertain, traditional methods may be more cost-effective.


• Existing Solutions: If current tools and methods are working well, there may be no need to switch to AI.

In this scenario, traditional financial analysis tools and human expertise can continue to provide value without the added cost and complexity of AI. The firm can revisit AI options in the future when the business has grown, and the investment makes more sense.

5. When the Business Needs Flexibility and Creativity
Example: A marketing agency that creates custom campaigns for clients.

AI excels at automating repetitive tasks, analyzing data, and making predictions based on patterns. However, it struggles with creativity and adaptability, which are essential in fields like marketing. A small marketing agency that specializes in creating custom campaigns for clients might find that AI tools, while helpful for data analysis or trend prediction, cannot replace the creative brainstorming and flexible thinking that are core to its success.

Why Traditional Methods are Preferred:

• Creativity: AI lacks the ability to think creatively or generate innovative ideas, making it less suitable for tasks that require out-of-the-box thinking.


• Adaptability: Businesses in dynamic industries need to adapt quickly to changes. Traditional methods allow for more flexibility and responsiveness.


• Human Intuition: Experienced marketers rely on intuition and experience to craft campaigns that resonate with target audiences, something AI cannot replicate.

For a marketing agency, traditional methods that prioritize creativity, human intuition, and adaptability are likely to deliver better results than AI. While AI can support the agency’s work, it should not replace the human elements that drive success.

Conclusion
AI offers exciting possibilities for small businesses, from automating routine tasks to providing advanced insights. However, it’s essential to recognize when AI is not the right choice. Whether it’s due to the simplicity of the problem, a lack of data, the need for a personal touch, cost considerations, or the importance of flexibility and creativity, there are times when traditional methods are preferred.

By carefully evaluating the specific needs and circumstances of their businesses, small business owners can make informed decisions about when to implement AI and when to rely on tried-and-true traditional methods. In many cases, the human touch, experience, and intuition that drive small businesses cannot be easily replaced by AI, and recognizing this can be the key to long-term success."

So, there are some instances when AI might not be the answer. We have to admit that not all problems are complex. If it's a simple problem or there is a clear path to a solution, then perhaps a traditional method is all you'll need. It doesn't mean that AI might not be in the future, but perhaps the traditional fix will patch things up for now.

Let's say, for example, that a customer's order was delayed because it was out of stock. This is an unusual occurrence for your company, as inventory management is normally not an issue. You can easily solve this problem by expediting the shipping to the customer when it's available, reimbursing the shipping cost, crediting part of the purchase price, sending a gift card or any combination of these things. The problem is solved quickly and cheaply. You don't need to run out and implement a new AI-based inventory management system that will cost 10s or 100s of thousands of dollars just yet. Monitor for trends first!

I've spoken about data multiple times in past articles. Data is the fuel for AI. Without it, there's very little that you can do. If your business doesn't generate and store a lot of data, then trying to implement AI will be like pushing a boulder up hill.

If you have a goal of implementing AI in your business, and I hope you do, then I'd suggest you start by generating data first. Begin by capturing and storing all your inventory detail, marketing data, sales transactions, customer service detail, etc. You can start with a spreadsheet, if necessary, but be prepared to move it to a local or cloud-based database before attempting anything with AI. Ensure that the data is high quality and as complete as possible. This will be a solid foundation on which you can begin to implement AI solutions!

Personal touch is probably the most important reason on this list. There are times when it's just better to have a human do something. Assuming the human is skilled in interacting with customers, then it will simply build a stronger relationship than having the customer interact with a chatbot.

Can you imagine going to buy a luxury home or exotic supercar and being forced to interact with a chat bot? You're about to drop millions on a home or hundreds of thousands on a car and no human in sight. You're expecting white glove treatment and deserve it for that type of purchase. A human should be guiding you through every step of the sales process!

The same goes for customer service issues as well. A chatbot might be able to handle small questions and issues, but major issues must be handled by a person who cares. Can you imagine having a new custom-made couch delivered to your home only to find out it was made with the wrong color upholstery? Now imagine that you can only talk to a chatbot online or an automated response system over the phone when you attempt to get the issue resolved. You'd be livid. You need someone to talk to who will empathize with your disappointment, treat your problem delicately and resolve it with a sense of urgency. You need a human!

The last one that I'll hit on is flexibility. Some businesses must be very agile. Particularly in the startup phase. AI can be self-learning and can adapt, but it can take more time than is available or it might cost a lot to adjust the AI model. It's usually better to get to some sort of steady state in your business, or at least the business function(s) in question, prior to investing in AI. It may end up slowing you down.

One example that comes to mind here is online sellers who have built their business model around only selling hot, trending items. Investing in an AI-base inventory management system that does auto ordering may not be advisable if it can't accurately determine the market demand for what you're selling. In some cases, items are only trendy for weeks or months. By the time the AI model has enough data to train itself on sales and ordering patterns, the product is old news and a new one is trending. You might be better off handling the ordering and inventory management processes yourself and save yourself a headache!

Do you agree with the suggestions above? Are there really times when AI isn't the answer? It's ultimately a personal decision based on your unique circumstances. I definitely believe that every problem or opportunity should be evaluated objectively and that all viable solutions should be considered. Strong discipline in vetting solutions will pay dividends!

Facing a problem and now know that a more traditional solution is in order? Maybe you got a little too excited about AI and tried to implement it for an opportunity requiring a traditional approach? Check out FailingCompany.com to find the help that you need. Go sign up for an account or log in to your existing account and start working with someone today.

#FailingCompany.com #SaveMyFailingCompany #ArtificialIntelligence #WhenNotToUseAI # #SaveMyBusiness #GetBusinessHelp